Get the most from your materiality assessments

New Zealand’s largest waste and environmental services provider Waste Management is among a growing number of companies using materiality assessments to ‘connect the dots’ across their business. In the four years our thinkstep-anz team has worked with them, they’ve used materiality assessment to:

  • engage their stakeholders
  • develop a sustainability strategy
  • set sustainability and business goals and targets
  • inform their decision-making
  • meet reporting requirements.

That’s quite an evolution! It’s also a good example of the value of tailoring materiality assessments to suit your organisation’s goals.

In this blog based on our webinar ‘Materiality: Connecting the dots’, Adam Weller, Sustainability Manager at Waste Management, and Jeff Vickers, thinkstep-anz’s Technical Director, offer real-life insights and expert knowledge to help you get the most from your materiality assessments.

Here are their tips.

1.  Look beyond ‘box ticking’: materiality offers so much more

At its core, a materiality assessment is about stakeholder engagement. By identifying and prioritising relevant sustainability issues, based on feedback from important external and internal groups, this approach helps businesses focus on the issues that matter most – to their stakeholders and to the business – and importantly identify what a future-focused low carbon waste company should look like

However, all too often, businesses see materiality assessments as ‘ticking a box’ to meet their requirements as a listed company or of reporting frameworks. The materiality process offers so much more.

2.  Start with the end in mind: your business needs

A materiality assessment is most effective when it is tailored to your organisation’s structure, requirements, and goals. Make sure you understand what you’re trying to achieve. Improve stakeholder engagement? Develop a sustainability policy and strategy? Satisfy sustainability reporting requirements for established frameworks? All these things?

In Waste Management’s case, the company has ambitious sustainability goals. Initially, they used their materiality assessment to guide their sustainability strategy and activities. Subsequently, they have used the information the assessment provides to develop their reporting.

3.  Just get started! (But think ahead)

It’s never too late to start a materiality assessment – or too early. If you’re short on time, a slimmed-down version may be your best option and will meet the needs of a sustainability report.

Be honest in your report about difficulties you encountered and disclose your plans to expand your materiality assessment in the future.

Think ahead. For example, if you want to use the results of your assessment to develop your strategy (as Waste Management did), start early.

4.  Identify your stakeholders and contact a broad cross-section

Stakeholders are groups who influence or are affected by your activities, products, services, and performance. Your staff and customers are important stakeholders. However, they can give you a partial view only.

For Waste Management, stakeholder engagement meant tapping into a network of ten external and ten internal groups. External organisations were given high importance.

Engagement took the form of detailed interviews conducted by Jeff Vickers from thinkstep-anz. In a workshop with 50 Waste Management leaders, participants then reviewed the results of these interviews, identified issues important to stakeholders and ranked these issues on their importance to the business.

Smaller companies may contact fewer stakeholders. However, for a well-rounded assessment, you should still seek the views of a broad cross-section. The most important stakeholder groups are investors, staff, boards, customers, suppliers, community, business partners and government.

5.  Frame your questions carefully to get a balanced perspective

Common stakeholder engagement techniques include interviews, focus groups, questionnaires, and workshops. It can be hard to connect with large groups like suppliers, local and regional government, and indigenous communities. Without previous experience or guidance, it can also be easy to miss out on critical stakeholder feedback.

Decide in advance which issues are likely to matter to your stakeholders but encourage them to look at a broad range. Distinguish the issues that are time-sensitive from those that are timeless: for example, the natural environment versus COVID-19.

Be consistent across groups, frame questions carefully, and seek balanced perspectives. Frameworks for identifying and engaging stakeholders (e.g. AccountAbility’s AA1000 Stakeholder Engagement Standard) can be helpful.

6.  Use materiality assessment to guide your sustainability strategy

In October 2018, Waste Management became the first waste service provider in New Zealand to release a detailed sustainability strategy: For Future Generations. This strategy identified five areas of activity the company planned to pursue to become truly sustainable. They focus on circular economy and preparing for a low-carbon world.

The strategy supports Waste Management’s goal of meeting the needs of today without compromising the chance for future generations to meet their own needs.

7.  Use materiality assessment to guide your reporting

In May 2020, Waste Management became the first New Zealand waste company to release a GRI sustainability report. They used the results of the materiality assessment to guide the report’s contents.

A materiality assessment will support many different reporting frameworks, including GRI and <IR>. You can choose to follow either, neither, or borrow elements from each. GRI was the right option for Waste Management: it focuses on a broad group of stakeholders and, as a private company, Waste Management does not need to release financial reports

8.  Use materiality assessment to set your goals – including long-term

 Waste Management has used materiality to review business goals and develop stretch goals and targets for 2025. They have also mapped their material issues against the framework provided by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals.

9.  Connect the dots!

Using a materiality assessment to improve stakeholder engagement is only the start of your sustainability journey. Use it to its full potential! Connect the dots between your strategy, the goals you set, the decisions you make, and your reporting.

 

June 2022

You might be interested in

Materiality assessment

Identify and prioritise sustainability matters relevant to your company by engaging with your customers, investors, suppliers, partners and employees directly. We can help you through the whole process.

resized omar flores MOO6k3RaiwE unsplash

Materiality webinar

This webinar will show you how to connect the dots and optimise materiality assessments for maximum value. 

Sustainability strategy

A materiality assessment can help you understand what's important for you and your stakeholders. It can also form an integral part of your sustainability strategy.